Global Affairs
Structural Cracks in Global Governance: The Return of Great Power Hegemony and the Logic of a New Order
Analyze the systemic challenges facing the current global governance system, explore the resurgence of great power nationalism and hegemonic politics eroding existing international norms, and examine the role of small and medium powers in reshaping the global governance structure, and forecast the new order forms under a multipolar background.
In the grand narrative of global governance, when existing international institutions and norms encounter structural cracks, predicting the future's form seems like sailing through a fog. From the perspective of the Carnegie Peace Institute, the future of the global order is not a linear development along a single path, but a complex product jointly constructed by self-interested great powers, reshaped existing institutions, or emerging alliances. The current "disorder" in the global landscape is the result of the interaction between long-accumulated institutional deficiencies and sudden shocks in geopolitics.
Firstly, the effectiveness of multilateralism is facing a severe test. Global forums often get bogged down in inefficiency and deadlock when dealing with complex issues. When there is a lack of trust in countries surrendering key governance decisions, consensus-based decision-making mechanisms turn into traps of delay. From the stagnation in multilateral negotiations at the World Trade Organization (WTO) to the long process of negotiating global health agreements, both expose the fragility of large multilateral frameworks in the absence of strong enforcement mechanisms. This crisis of efficacy gives rise to new governance needs: how to incorporate the complexity of the global agenda into an actionable framework.
Secondly, changes in economic centers and power structures are accelerating the collapse of the old order. The rise of emerging powers like BRICS, and their demands for reform in international financial and governance institutions, often create structural conflicts with the interests of established dominant forces. This power shift is not a smooth institutional evolution but one accompanied by renegotiation of existing power distribution. If emerging powers can effectively coordinate and push for adjustments in leadership over core institutions like the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank, the speed of this power transition will far exceed traditional expectations.
A deeper structural contradiction lies in the tension between "innovation and mission creep." When the global agenda shifts from traditional issues to cross-cutting issues like climate change and gender equality, existing governance architectures often prove inadequate, lacking both the expertise to address new challenges and falling into disarray due to the expansion of the agenda. This prompts the emergence of new forms of governance—through non-traditional actors such as transnational networks (TGNs), multinational corporations, and non-governmental organizations (NGOs)—to engage in more flexible and complex cooperation with state governments, filling the vacuum left by formal institutions. This "hybrid governance" model, while showing resilience in crisis response, also brings the risks of dispersed decision-making power and unequal influence.
The resurgence of great power competition is essentially a return to the logic of "nationalism" and "strongman politics." This is not a simple return to the ideologies of the Cold War, but a concentration of power characterized by "strongman politics," which prioritizes national interests above cross-national ideologies. Whether it is China reshaping its past glory or Russia's extreme emphasis on national sovereignty, both reflect a systemic challenge to existing international norms—a redefinition of territorial integrity and political autonomy.
The consequence of this challenge is that international relations are shifting from early ideological confrontation to geopolitical struggles centered on "strongmen" and greater purpose.The consequence of this challenge is that international relations have shifted from early ideological confrontation to a more purposeful geopolitical game centered on "strongmen." The rise of nationalism has made "systemic resistance" against international law and multilateral institutions a political logic. This logic is not only reflected in the distancing from international treaties but also in the intention to structurally reorganize the existing distribution of power.
Looking ahead, the form of global governance will present a state of high "tension coexistence." On one hand, while the ideal form of global governance may still exist due to the remnants of universal values and liberal norms, this idealism will be strongly corrected by great power politics. On the other hand, the new order will be highly fragmented and hybrid. It will no longer be dominated by a single supranational entity, but will be woven together by the complex interest struggles between regional blocs, transnational corporate alliances, and states and non-state actors. True resilience will no longer depend on a perfect global constitution, but on the dynamic capacity of each party to seek adaptation and reconstruction amidst uncertainty.
Record and limits · obsrpost
obsrpost frames this note through Observer Post is an analysis-first global news and commentary publication for international affairs, market... - dates, names and status changes still need checking. Top Stories / City Briefs / Policy Updates explains the local editorial angle; Source links should be opened before the summary is reused.